Do you call yourself a consultant or a contractor (and why does it matter)?

Posted on Jul 11th, 2016 | Tax

Whether it’s to increase their kudos in the contractor community or to improve their bottom line, every contractor wants to be known as a consultant. Whatever their motivation, the term consultant is a highly sought-after title – and for good reason.

Successful marketing is all about packaging yourself and doing it well.

Calling yourself a consultant or a contractor isn’t about semantics. Consulting and contracting aren’t the same thing. Their differences can make a huge difference to your prestige – and your pay packet.

Consulting and contracting defined

Definitions of consulting and contracting are a dime a dozen.

While the terms aren’t mutually exclusive, the role of a consultant is, in general, to evaluate their clients’ needs and provide them with expert advice on what work needs to be done. Whereas a contractor’s role is often to carry out the work itself.

Essentially, consultants are paid for their knowledge, contractors for their work.

This is something of a broad-brush contrast, but it does provide an illustration of how consulting can be distinguished from contracting. Here are some of the finer details.

Consultants

When they bring their A-game, consultants can be game-changers.

They can bring about 180-degree shifts in management thinking and dramatic improvements in business performance.

A consultant is typically a self-employed, seasoned professional who brings to the table bags of knowledge, skills, and training in their area of expertise.

They’re drafted in when a client has a pressing issue that they neither have the time nor the capability of resolving. Exercising their autonomy and professional judgement, a consultant then does whatever they see fit to deliver a solution that meets the client’s needs.

A consultant often works in an advisory capacity. In return for a fee, they carry out an assessment of an entire business or a particular business area and make suggestions about how to make improvements.

So, more often than not, a consultant won’t actually get involved in the daily grind of making the improvements needed. Instead, they steer their client on how best to implement their recommendations.

Contractors

Much like a consultant, a contractor tends to be a skilled, self-employed professional.

Not wanting to add to their tally of permanent staff, clients hire their services – on a contract basis – for a limited time only. A contractor routinely works onsite at their client’s premises and they do so under direct supervision, so they’re told what to do, how to do it and when it needs to be done.

Although a contractor can (and often does) advise their client on what work should be done, their main focus is on getting the work done and dusted.

Impact on fees

money 4The importance of the consultant / contractor distinction lies in the power of perception and how that can affect the level of fees you can command from your client.

While a consultant typically enters their client’s business at executive level, a contractor is commonly viewed as somewhat subordinate – part of the workforce furniture, if you will. Consequently, a consultant can generally attract higher fees than a contractor. Rather than just offering their time to their client, a consultant markets solutions to their client’s problems and this is reflected in their billing practices.

For instance, a contractor issues their clients with invoices exclusively based on their time spent providing services – whether this is calculated hourly, daily or project-based. By contrast, a consultant invoices their clients based on the quality of the solution and the consumer demand for it – not solely the time spent providing their services.

How to make progress as a consultant or contractor

To make waves as a consultant, you’ll need to stay abreast of industry developments.
Spend some time learning about evolving concepts and theoretical approaches to problems without getting weighed down by the ins and outs of the practical execution.

Your grand plan should be to find out why certain things work and others don’t. For example, as a brand consultant working on a client’s logo, you may need to swot up on consumer psychology to understand how consumers respond to different colours. Knowing about the importance of a seemingly minor detail like this could mean the difference between your client’s customers browsing their products or services and buying them.

As a contractor, your task is a lot more straightforward. All you need is the ability to do the job you’re contracted to do – just as you would if you were applying for a permanent spot.

Occasionally, you may get a chance to crossover from contracting to consulting. Opportunity knocks when a client brings you onboard as a contractor, but has precious little idea of exactly what it is they need you to do.

This is your chance to shine by volunteering advice that would ordinarily fall within the remit of a consultant. Whilst you may not get paid for the advisory aspect, it could give you a wealth of experience and put you in good stead for nailing a consulting role in the future (if that’s what you’re after).

Irrespective of whether you call yourself a consultant or a contractor, a client will ultimately hire you on merit. But if you position yourself as a consultant by providing tailored solutions for your client’s pain points, you could ease your way to a much higher fee.

Join Crunch Chorus:
The free community for the self-employed

You'll get access to a range of benefits, such as invoice software, jargon-free business guides, great networking opportunities, discounts, plus much more

Written by Kieron Johnson

Useful tools and resources

Business guides

From understanding expenses to starting a limited company, we've a range of jargon-free business guides for you to download and keep.

Invoicing software and templates

Create, send and store sole trader invoices in a snap with our free invoice software. You can also download a selection of invoice templates for all business types.

Take-home pay calculator

Use our Take-Home Pay Calculator to work out your true earnings and see if you could save money with a different company set up.

We make accounting simple

With Crunch, you’ll have unlimited advice and support from your dedicated client manager and our team of accountants, alongside innovative online accounting software so you can keep on top of your bookkeeping with ease. No appointments, no fuss.

Find out more