Is being VAT registered hurting your small business?

If you’ve registered for VAT or are thinking about it, you might be wondering whether it’s really benefiting your small business. While VAT registration can offer certain advantages, such as reclaiming VAT on business expenses, it can also bring challenges like extra paperwork, cash flow issues, and higher prices for your customers.

In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of VAT registration, helping you decide whether it’s the right choice for your business.

The pros and cons of being VAT registered

VAT registration comes with both benefits and challenges, and understanding these can help you decide if it’s right for your small business.

The benefits

• It boosts your credibility. VAT registration can make your business look more professional and established, which could attract larger clients or suppliers.
  
  
• You can expand your client base. If you sell to other VAT-registered businesses, they can reclaim the VAT you charge, making your offerings more attractive to them.
  
  
• Avoid late registration penalties. By registering for VAT early, you avoid penalties that can arise if your turnover exceeds the £90,000 threshold and you haven’t registered yet.
  
  
• You can reclaim VAT on capital assets. Large purchases like machinery or vehicles can be more affordable with VAT registration since you can reclaim the VAT.
  
  
• You can reclaim VAT on expenses. VAT-registered businesses on the Standard rate scheme can reclaim VAT on most business expenses, helping offset costs. However, if you're on the Flat Rate scheme, you can only reclaim VAT on capital assets over £2,000 (VAT inclusive) and certain pre-registration expenses.

The disadvantages

• Increased admin work. VAT registration requires keeping detailed records, filing VAT returns regularly, and ensuring compliance with VAT regulations, creating an added administrative burden.
  
  
• Cash flow impact. You must pay VAT to HMRC regardless of when you receive payment from customers, which can cause cash flow issues, especially if you're waiting for payments.
  
  
• Higher prices for customers. As a VAT-registered business, you’ll add VAT to your prices. While VAT-registered businesses can reclaim it, non-VAT customers can’t, which could make your products or services more expensive.
  
  
• Risk of penalties. Non-compliance with VAT rules, whether it’s late filings or mistakes in your records, can lead to penalties or audits from HMRC.
  
  
• No VAT reclaim on non-VAT-registered purchases. If you work with non-VAT-registered customers or suppliers, you can’t reclaim VAT on those purchases, reducing the financial benefits of being VAT registered.
  
  

While VAT registration can offer tax savings and boost your business image, it’s important to weigh these benefits against the additional administrative responsibilities and potential cash flow impacts.

How to decide if VAT registration is right for your business

Consider your turnover and growth potential

The first factor to consider is your business’s turnover. If you're approaching the VAT threshold of £90,000 (for the 2025/26 tax year), it's worth starting to think about VAT registration. If your business is growing rapidly and you expect to exceed this threshold soon, registering for VAT early can help avoid the stress of last-minute registration and the penalties that may come with failing to comply.

If your turnover is significantly below the threshold and you don’t expect it to rise anytime soon, you may want to think carefully before registering. The administrative work and potential for higher pricing could outweigh the benefits, especially if you don’t have a large number of VAT-registered customers who can reclaim the VAT you charge.

Evaluate your customer base

Another important factor is who you’re selling to. If your customers are mostly other VAT-registered businesses, registering for VAT can work in your favor. They can reclaim the VAT you charge them, which can make your services or products more appealing.

However, if your customer base is mainly made up of non-VAT-registered businesses or individual consumers, registering for VAT might increase your prices and make you less competitive. For smaller businesses selling to individuals, this can be a significant downside.

Assess the impact on your cash flow

VAT registration can affect your cash flow, as you’ll need to pay the VAT you collect to HMRC before you receive payment from your customers. If your business is heavily reliant on credit sales or has slow-paying clients, this could put strain on your cash flow.

Before registering, make sure you have solid cash flow management in place, and consider whether your business can afford the upfront costs of VAT payments before your customers pay their invoices. 

Where possible, Crunch uses the cash basis to make VAT simpler for our clients. This means you only pay VAT once you've actually received payment from your customers, helping to reduce the strain on your cash flow.

Weigh the administrative costs and time commitment

Being VAT registered comes with extra administrative duties, including maintaining records, submitting VAT returns, and ensuring compliance. If you're a small business with limited time or resources, these additional responsibilities might feel overwhelming. You’ll need to weigh whether you have the capacity to handle this extra workload, or if it would be better to hire external help, like an accountant, to manage the VAT process.

If your business is small and you don't yet have the systems in place to efficiently manage VAT, it may be wise to postpone registration until you’re ready. On the other hand, if you can automate your processes or afford to bring in professional help, VAT registration might be easier to manage.

What to do if you’re already VAT registered and it’s not working for your business

1. Check if you’re eligible for voluntary deregistration

If your business turnover has dropped below the VAT registration threshold of £88,000, you may be eligible to deregister voluntarily. This means you can stop charging VAT on your sales and no longer have to submit VAT returns or comply with VAT-related record-keeping.

Before making this decision, ensure that your turnover is consistently below the threshold and that you can maintain your financial health without VAT registration. Voluntary deregistration might be particularly beneficial if your business is mainly selling to non-VAT registered customers and the added VAT is negatively impacting your pricing or competitiveness.

2. Consider partial exemption (if applicable)

If you’re VAT registered but you only make taxable supplies part of the time (for example, some of your sales are exempt or outside the scope of VAT), you may be eligible for partial exemption. This allows you to reclaim VAT on your business expenses proportionally to the taxable portion of your activities.

3. Simplify your VAT processes

If you’re feeling overwhelmed by the administrative requirements, there are ways to simplify the process. Consider using accounting software that automates VAT calculations and submissions. Many platforms integrate directly with HMRC’s Making Tax Digital (MTD) system, making VAT returns much easier to manage.

You could also use accountant or bookkeeper services to take care of your VAT-related tasks, giving you more time to focus on running your business. Outsourcing can be an efficient solution if managing VAT takes too much of your time and resources. 

4. Reassess your pricing strategy

If VAT registration is hurting your pricing strategy, especially with non-VAT registered customers, you might need to revisit your pricing model. If you can’t afford to absorb the VAT costs yourself and your customers are feeling the pinch, you might need to explore ways to justify your pricing or offer added value elsewhere to keep your competitive edge.

For example, bundling services or offering discounts for bulk orders might offset the impact of higher prices. Alternatively, reviewing your supplier relationships and expenses to find more VAT savings could also help you adjust your pricing to be more competitive.

Is being VAT registered killing your business?

Ultimately, deciding whether to be VAT registered depends on the unique nature of your business. By carefully evaluating your turnover, pricing structure, customer base, and growth plans, you can decide whether the time and effort involved in VAT registration is worth the rewards.

Making the right business choice

Navigating VAT doesn’t have to be a headache. With Crunch, you get more than just accounting software—you gain access to expert accountants who can guide you through the complexities of VAT and help you maximise its benefits.

Ultimately, whether VAT registration is the right move for your small business depends on your unique circumstances. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, but with the right information and planning, you can make an informed choice that supports the long-term success of your business.

Take the time to assess your situation, understand the full implications of VAT, and consult with experts if needed. By doing so, you’ll set your business up for success. 

Get VAT guidance today with Crunch

‍