Is it fair? HMRC charges 7.25% on late payments but only repays 3.75%

Is it fair HMRC charges 7.25% on late tax but repays only 3.75%
Picture of crunch software on mobile

Professional Bio Templates & Examples

Create a compelling professional narrative for a proper, attention-grabbing introduction.
Website bios
Speaker intros
Professional Profile

HMRC recently announced an interest rate change for late tax payments, lowering the rate from 7.5% to 7.25% from November 18th. 

This adjustment follows a cut in the Bank of England’s base rate, but the reduced rate might not feel like much of a relief for taxpayers who end up paying more interest than they’d receive on a refund. While late payment interest remains high, the rate for taxpayers owed refunds from HMRC is only 3.75%. Is this imbalance fair?

Why the difference?

The interest HMRC charges is set at the Bank of England’s base rate plus 2.5%, while the rate for refunds is lower, typically around the base rate plus 0.5%. This setup allows HMRC to charge higher rates on late payments than it offers on overpayments. 

Many tax experts have argued that this creates an unfair situation, especially for the self-employed, who may face challenges in balancing multiple tax deadlines. With the January 31st Self-Assessment deadline on the horizon, this disparity puts more pressure on those who need to get their tax affairs in order.

{{pt-self-assessment}}

What this means for taxpayers

For anyone struggling to meet the Self Assessment deadline, the high 7.25% interest rate can quickly add up, especially if payment delays extend beyond a few months. And with late payment interest stacking up alongside penalties, the consequences of missing deadlines become costly. 

On the flip side, taxpayers owed refunds will receive only 3.75% interest – far lower than the rate they’d be charged if they were the ones owing.

What can taxpayers do?

The best way to avoid the impact of these differing rates is to stay on top of tax payments and deadlines. For the self-employed, this means preparing for the January deadline well in advance, organising finances, and ensuring accurate calculations. Seeking support from an online accountant, like Crunch, can be invaluable for managing these complexities, avoiding penalties, and ensuring deadlines are met.

As the discussion on interest rates continues, many believe HMRC should review its policies to create a fairer system. For now, taxpayers should remain aware of the potential costs of late payments – and plan accordingly.

Speak to an accounting expert

If you're unsure what level of support you need, our friendly team are on hand to help you pick the right package for you.
Self Assessment tax returns done for you, from just £200+VAT
Take the stress out of Sole Trader Accounting, with our simple online software, so you can look after your accounts anytime, anywhere.
Share this post
Vicki Nichols
Marketing communications & content executive
Updated on
November 16, 2024

Knowledge Hubs

Take control of your accounts, today

Crunch’s effective software package includes being able to talk to an expert client manager and a Chartered Certified Accountant. You can count on Crunch to make you productive and profitable.

Save your seat! Live e-commerce webinar

Register and soak in the wisdom from top industry leader! June 27, 2024 1:30 PM
Dive into e-commerce basics
Expert industry insights
Practical tips and savvy tricks
Pro Tip
Wondering how the Autumn Budget affects your bottom line?

Download our guide for expert insights from an accountant, tailored for business owners and the self-employed.

Pro Tip
Work out the tax you owe in seconds

Discover your true take-home pay with our self-employed tax calculator – see exactly what you’ll keep after tax, National Insurance, and expenses.

Pro Tip
Want to know how much National Insurance you owe?

Find out exactly what you owe on your income in seconds with our free National Insurance calculator.

Pro Tip
Want to know how much mileage you can claim for?

Our free mileage allowance calculator can help you see in seconds what you could get back.

Pro Tip
Want to work out your income tax?

Find out what Income Tax and National Insurance you owe on your earnings with our free tax calculator.

Pro Tip
Want to work out what your Capital Gains Tax bill?

Our free Capital Gains Tax calculator shows what tax you owe on any property, stocks or gifts.

Pro Tip
Want to know how much dividend tax you owe?

Find out exactly what you owe on your investments in seconds with our free dividend tax calculator.

Pro Tip
Want to see what we're currently working on?

Our public roadmap shows what we're working on and what's coming next. You can even vote on what features we work on next!

Pro Tip
Your ultimate guide to stress-free taxes

Tackling taxes can be tough! Get our "Ultimate tax guide for the self-employed" now to make it easier.

Pro Tip
Claim your FREE ecommerce guide today

Curious how great accounting can boost your e-commerce business? Download our guide to discover 8 key ways!

Pro Tip
Unlock the secrets of Ltd company expenses

Don't miss out on potential tax savings - get access to our 'Limited Company Expense' guide today!

Pro Tip
Want to make sure you don't miss any tips?

Sign up to our newsletter for expert insights, tax news and other essential updates that will keep your business thriving. Subscribe now!

Pro Tip
Ready to save big on Ecommerce accounting?

Crush your current accounting and software fees by up to 60%. Put us to the test and watch your savings soar!

Pro Tip
Looking for a dedicated accountant?

Our Enterprise packages offer tailored support for you and your business. You can focus on your business, we'll crunch the numbers.

Pro Tip
Boost your business finances with our Ltd Company packages!

Award-winning software with support from expert accountants

Pro Tip
Take the stress out of Sole Trader Accounting

Real-time insights, expert support—stay on top of your finances with ease.

Pro Tip
File your Tax Return

Get your tax return sorted by experts for only £200+VAT!

Pro Tip
Using cloud-based accountancy software to manage your finances gives any small business a big advantage!

At Crunch we provide affordable cutting-edge, easy-to-use software with real human support from expert chartered accountants. That’s probably why 81% of our clients would recommend Crunch.

Pro Tip
Want access to real expert accountants?

All our accounting packages include free access to Chartered Certified Accountants, so you can make confident business decisions without worrying about extra costs racking up.

Pro Tip
File you Tax Return!

Crunch’s Self Assessment service provides an expert accountant to complete, check, and file your Self Assessment for you for just £200 +VAT.

Pro Tip
Did you know - We have a free plan that is great for sole traders and limited companies?

Why not see for yourself? It’s simple and easy to use and 100% free.